A full roof replacement means stripping the existing roofing down to the deck (or in some cases overlaying, though tear-off is the better long-term choice in a climate like Madison's), repairing or replacing any damaged sheathing, installing new underlayment and ice-and-water shield, then laying new shingles, metal, or tile along with flashing, vents, and drip edge. It's a bigger job than a repair or a reroof patch, usually taking one to three days for a typical single-family home, and it's the point at which you can also address ventilation, insulation, and ice-dam protection that a simple patch job would leave untouched.
Madison winters are hard on roofs, so a contractor's experience with ice dams, proper attic ventilation, and ice-and-water barrier placement matters more here than in milder climates. Before signing anything, check for a current Wisconsin contractor registration, proof of general liability and workers' comp insurance, and manufacturer certification if you want a strong shingle warranty (many brands only honor their best warranties when installed by certified crews). Ask for a written scope of work that spells out tear-off, decking repair pricing, underlayment type, flashing details, and cleanup, not just a lump-sum number. A firm that shows up for the estimate, measures the roof itself, and explains its ventilation plan is usually a safer bet than one that quotes a price over the phone.
We rank the 7 roof replacement companies serving Madison on factors like verified licensing and insurance, review consistency over time, responsiveness, and how well complaints (if any) were resolved, not just star averages. See the full ranked guide to Madison roofing contractors for the breakdown, and read our methodology for exactly how we score and weight each factor.
Get matched with roof replacement in Madison
Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.
7 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is roof replacement, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Temple Roofing consistently delivers fast, professional work with teams that arrive on time and finish efficiently, often ahead of schedule. Reviews highlight staff by name-Joshua Wilkins, Michael, Tyler, and Brandon-for their knowledge, responsiveness, and willingness to answer questions and follow up.
Kyle, Robert, and Jordan consistently go beyond standard repair work, especially when navigating insurance claims after storm damage. Reviewers praise their honesty about what repairs are truly needed rather than settling for patch jobs, their patience explaining the process, and their willingness to fight for full coverage on the customer's behalf. The crew handles everything from emergency tarps to full roof replacement, often completing jobs in a single day. Customers highlight fair pricing, meticulous workmanship, thorough site cleanup, and the personal touch of staff treating homes as their own.
Red Roofing builds trust through clear communication and detailed inspections. Zach, Brandon, Aaron, Andrew, and Kevin are named repeatedly for professionalism and speed. They provide comprehensive photo reports, handle insurance claims, and finish jobs promptly, often staying late to complete measurements in poor weather. One reviewer discovered leaks months after a repair, questioning whether work was done as billed; another noted timeline delays but credited Brandon with personal follow-up to resolve the issue.
Multiple reviewers praised named project managers (Rafael, Christian, Bryson, Matthew, Kaleb) for clear communication, explaining work step-by-step, and staying available throughout replacement and repair jobs. Crews completed one-day replacements, cleaned up debris thoroughly, and helped navigate insurance claims. However, a small number of reviews documented significant concerns: damage to property (stucco, flagstone, gutters) during installation not fully corrected, quoted work (gutters, flashing) left incomplete, and lack of follow-up on warranty issues. Pricing concerns and paperwork delays were also noted. Named staff like Curtis Tucker, Christian, and James were cited for professionalism and going above expectations. Strong cleanup was mentioned across multiple jobs. One reviewer noted the business assisted neighbors with hail damage claims, and another documented Matthew's extra effort when other inspectors failed to approve damage.
From initial contact to final walkthrough, Talmadge Roofing delivers work that matches or exceeds what homeowners expect. Matt Siso leads a crew that communicates daily via photos, responds same-day to inquiries, and cleans up thoroughly, leaving no debris behind. The team handles roof replacements, repairs, and inspections with equal care. They guide customers through insurance claims step-by-step, coordinate with adjusters, and complete jobs in single days when possible. Communities and HOAs specifically praise their respect for shared spaces and safety protocols.
Get matched with roof replacement in Madison
Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.
Gary Bratcher handles jobs directly as the owner and roofer, making him accessible for customer questions. Reviews highlight his honesty and straightforward manner.
Both reviews praise professionalism, efficiency, and clear communication through the job. Reviewers named Crystal and Mike as knowledgeable, and appreciated competitive pricing on a commercial roof replacement.
Enquiries submitted through our forms may be passed to partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-08-26