Roof replacement means stripping the existing roof down to the deck (or in some cases layering over it, where code allows) and installing a new system: underlayment, flashing, ventilation, and a new surface material such as asphalt shingles, metal panels, tile, or a flat membrane. It's a different job from a repair or a partial reroof. A full replacement addresses hidden problems like rotted decking, poor attic ventilation, and outdated flashing details around chimneys and skylights, issues that a patch job can't fix and that shorten the life of even a brand-new surface if left alone.
Columbus adds its own wrinkles: freeze-thaw cycles that stress shingles and seams, occasional hail and wind events, and older housing stock in neighborhoods like Clintonville, German Village, and Merion Village where roof lines, decking, and ventilation weren't built to modern standards. A contractor who works regularly in those conditions will know how to handle valleys, ice damming, and attic airflow correctly, not just staple down shingles.
We've listed 65 roof replacement contractors serving the Columbus area. Before hiring, check for a current Ohio contractor license and insurance, a written scope of work (tear-off, decking repair terms, underlayment type, flashing, ventilation, cleanup), manufacturer certifications tied to the warranty being offered, and local reviews that mention follow-through after the job, not just the sales visit. Our scoring weighs verified reviews, complaint history, licensing, and consistency of service over time, so you're comparing substance, not just star counts. See how we calculate it on the methodology page, or jump straight to the ranked guide to Columbus roofing contractors to see who comes out on top.
Get matched with roof replacement in Columbus
Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.
33 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is roof replacement, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Brian and the crew show up on schedule, treat your property with respect, and finish installations clean. Many customers return for a second project after their first roof replacement, citing honesty during inspections and transparent pricing as reasons they stick with the team.
Jasmine Granville and Dominic lead this outfit through roofing, renovation, and general construction jobs with uncommon attentiveness. They answer questions directly, finish on schedule, and sweep up thoroughly, leaving customers reaching for superlatives about the entire experience. Storm damage, new roofs, gutter work, bathroom remodels, and miscellaneous repairs all come through polished. Staff explain their steps plainly, keep owners in the loop at every stage, and treat urgent jobs (roof leaks, termite damage) with real urgency. Many clients book them again for the next project.
Crosby Roofing delivers consistent five-star service across roof and gutter work. Hayden and his crew earn praise for quick callbacks, transparent pricing, and finishing jobs the same day. Customers highlight the owner's personal attention and crew professionalism, from roof tearoff to final walkthrough, making the experience straightforward and reliable.
Herschel leads a crew known for completing residential roofs in a single day while leaving zero debris behind. Bill handles estimates with detailed site inspections and clear quotes, and the team keeps owners informed via photos throughout the project. Every review emphasizes speed without cutting corners, and multiple customers report calling them back for additional properties. Storm damage work and fascia repairs also appear regularly in reviews, alongside roof replacements. The business handles jobs ranging from single-family homes to large commercial facilities with equal attention. Customers note competitive pricing paired with transparent pricing communication and follow-up calls after completion.
Dave and his crew earned 95% five-star reviews by delivering roof replacement and repair work in one day, cleaning up thoroughly, and often adding extras like pressure-washing or gutter painting at no charge. What sets them apart is Dave's personal involvement: he walks customers through insurance claims, responds fast to initial calls, and manages the entire process with visible care. One customer reported struggling for two months to get a warranty leak addressed after an otherwise successful replacement, but this sits isolated among 19 strongly positive recent reviews that consistently praise communication, speed, and professionalism. Their service areas span Columbus, Atlanta, Newnan, and Albany in Georgia, plus Auburn and Tuskegee in Alabama. Dave guides customers through storm-damage claims, emergency repairs, and leak detection as parts of the same hands-on approach reviewers mention for roof work. The business states it has operated over two decades and lists itself as fully licensed. A $250 referral bonus is available through their website.
Get matched with roof replacement in Columbus
Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.
Gary Kent and his crew deliver reliable roof work backed by 37 years of experience. Customers consistently report fast turnaround times, fair pricing, and meticulous site cleanup. The owner actively supervises jobs, answers calls promptly, and helps navigate insurance claims. His team handles roof replacement in a single day when feasible, tackles storm damage quickly, and solves unforeseen structural issues with clear options. Customers praise the crew's professionalism and the respectful way they treat homes and neighborhoods throughout the job.
Work typically finishes in one day with crews arriving early and staying focused. Reviewers consistently praise named project managers (Ernest, Pierce, Allen) for daily photo updates, respectful communication, and hands-on oversight. Most jobs involve complete cleanup; one reviewer found nails and debris after rushing at dusk but noted the team responded honestly to concerns. Materials and specs are explained in detail before installation. Poly shingles, fire-and-ice underlayment, drip edge, and proper ventilation are standard. One installation omitted a ventilation membrane, caught only after the fact. Another job involved the wrong shingle color, which the crew offered to correct. Despite these rare missteps, reviewers report strong rapport with the named foreman and crew members.
Frank Savage and his crew deliver roof replacements and commercial work with speed, often finishing large jobs in a day or two despite challenging weather. Reviewers consistently note competitive pricing, meticulous cleanup, and Frank's hands-on communication style, with regular photo updates and plain explanations of options and timelines.
Matter-of-Fact Roofing handles everything from emergency repairs to full replacements with transparency and calm efficiency. Reviewers consistently highlight Scott and Silas for walking them through each step, keeping sites debris-free, and following up weeks later to check on work. The company navigates insurance claims without pressure and offers financing options. One reviewer called the experience "a refreshing encounter with a lifecycle friend" rather than a transactional repair job. Staff arrive on schedule, complete projects the same day when possible, and treat property with the same care they'd give their own. Multiple customers noted they contacted their insurance mid-claim to advocate for better coverage and continued supporting owners through the process start to finish. The crew uses tarps strategically and leaves no nails or debris behind.
Matthew leads Baseline Coatings with hands-on professionalism that stands apart. Customers consistently report he solves persistent roof issues (including leaks prior contractors failed to fix), arrives on schedule, keeps them informed, and charges fairly. Work quality and cleanliness after jobs wrap up earn repeat business.
Liberty Roofing Professionals delivers consistent, single-day roof work across Columbus. Reviewers regularly praise the speed and professionalism of named crew members-Josh, Ky, Mitch, and Mitchell lead projects with clear communication and attentive site management from start to final walkthrough. The team handles both repair and replacement jobs with visible attention to detail: crews clean up after themselves, explain what is needed upfront, and keep homeowners informed throughout. Financing options and same-day emergency response appear to be standard practices that set them apart in the local market.
Five-star reviews across 17 Google ratings show work that blends seamlessly with existing roofs, gets done without delays, and solves problems previous contractors missed. The crew communicates clearly, cleans up thoroughly, and handles leak repairs and roof work with visible attention to matching materials and reinforcing long-term protection.
All 12 reviews award five stars, highlighting staff responsiveness and careful attention to property and customer communication. Davis and Jessie are named for managing jobs efficiently, answering questions quickly, and standing behind work on replacements, repairs, and gutter installations.
Most customers praise Danny Renfroe Roofing for on-time service, thorough cleanup including magnetic nail sweeps, and fair pricing. Shane Renfroe and the crew earn consistent respect for quality work, honest assessments (declining jobs when roofs don't need replacement), and going beyond the original scope. Two early complaints cite missed appointments and billing disputes; the recent pattern is strongly positive.
Alan Townsend arrives fast, finds leaks other roofers miss, and prices fairly. His crew works cleanly and finishes fast, matching shingles by eye after 40 years in the trade. One complaint alleges incomplete work on vents and flashing three years ago, leaving the homeowner needing repairs elsewhere. Reviewers trust him enough to refer family and handle storm damage while waiting on insurance. He does roof repairs, replacements, and inspections across Columbus and surrounding areas, often completing jobs in a day or less. Many mention getting estimates the next morning after calling.
Steve and his crew consistently deliver professional installation work paired with transparent customer service. Reviewers highlight the owner's willingness to educate homeowners on proper techniques and product choices, not just upsell, and praise the team's punctuality, courtesy, and attention to detail from initial estimate through project completion and cleanup. The business excels at window and door replacement, gutter installation with proper engineering (drip edge, toppers, downspout placement), and shop roofing repairs. Named crew members-Steve, Nick, JP, and Kevin-appear frequently in reviews. Multiple customers report the team proactively identifies secondary issues and fixes them without charging, and the owner has resolved disputes with competing contractors on the customer's behalf.
Get matched with roof replacement in Columbus
Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.
Most reviewers report quick, clean work. A recent one-star post questions whether the business is genuinely local to Columbus, noting reviews appear to come from multiple states.
When a named technician is assigned, work is solid and communication stays on track. Project delays and office communication lapses are the consistent friction point, especially on insurance claims where estimates have been bungled and timelines stretch far beyond initial forecasts.
When Weather Shielders shows up, work quality and pricing satisfy most customers, with Shane earning particular praise for honesty and budget flexibility. Repeat no-shows, unreturned calls, and at least one warranty dispute that went unresolved create a serious reliability risk.
Stormproof Roofing Solutions completes projects on schedule with attention to detail and a clean workspace. Donovan and his team earn repeated praise for professional service, transparent communication, and quality workmanship across roof replacements and repairs.
Expert Roofers Columbus holds a 4.7 rating across 77 reviews, with 84% five-star marks. Review detail is limited, but the volume and consistency suggest solid customer satisfaction across their full service range.
Strong work on initial jobs and emergency response, but serious follow-up problems. Several older reviews praise quick repairs and insurance coordination, yet others report warranty claims abandoned for months and no-shows on scheduled visits. Recent complaints about unpaid vendor invoices and unanswered calls suggest operational strain.
Four five-star reviews describe fast, high-quality work with the owner personally checking job progress. Reviewers note clear communication and honest dealings throughout roof replacement and repair projects.
All five reviews are five-star. Reviewers call this the best roofing company in Georgia and praise quality work, timely service, and 50+ years in the area. Coverage spans residential, commercial, metal, and sheet metal specialties.
All four reviews award five stars. Christian leads consultations with strong product knowledge and follows through on commitments. Teams finish jobs quickly, work hard, and leave sites clean, though one reviewer noted nails scattered around the roof edge afterward.
Richard and his team show up fast and focus on what you actually need, not what pads their invoice. They handle insurance claims, use quality materials, and clean up after the job.
One Google review rates this Columbus business five stars. Detail is limited, so broader assessment depends on their stated 10+ years of experience and service range.
Limited review data. One five-star rating supports the business's emergency and restoration claims, though detail on specific services remains scarce.
One five-star review recommends the business, though limited detail is available. Their website claims to offer roof repair, replacement, metal roofing, inspections, and gutter services across Columbus and nearby areas.
Review text is not available for Azly Roofing. The business operates from Columbus and lists roof repairs, shingle replacement, roof installation, storm damage, flashing, and gutter work. Their website states they are licensed and insured, and serve Georgia.
Review evidence is limited; no customer feedback text is available for this listing. The business states it offers appliance and HVAC services through Sears Home Services, with certified technicians and diagnostic fees ranging from $90 to $150.
No customer reviews are available for this business. To assess service quality and reliability, check their phone number or website directly for references or recent customer feedback.
Limited review detail is available. Wolf Roofing & Remodeling operates in Columbus and claims to serve residential and commercial roofing, repair, and inspection across Georgia.
Enquiries submitted through this site's contact forms may be passed to partner providers who can perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-09-15