Best roofing contractors in Columbus

★★★★★4.9 (155 reviews)

Superior Roofing Columbus posts the highest composite score on this list, built on a large, consistent run of five-star feedback. Brian personally handles consultations and oversight, and reviewers repeatedly point to honest, transparent pricing as the reason they call the crew back for a second project.

• Free appraisals with honest, no-pressure roof inspections
• No charge for minor repairs found during an appraisal
• Brian personally handles consultations and oversees projects
• Crew leaves job sites spotless after installation

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.9 (68 reviews)

Supreme Service Company earns its score from fast, thorough work on everything from emergency repairs to full renovations, with Jasmine and Dominic Granville named again and again for same-day responsiveness. Certification across every major shingle brand backs up the storm-damage and insurance-claim work that dominates the review set.

• Same-day response on emergency calls, including after-hours
• Named staff (Jasmine and Dominic Granville) known for professionalism
• Handles insurance claims and storm damage from start to finish
• Certified installer for Tamko, Atlas, Owens Corning, and GAF

Services: gutter services

★★★★★5 (50 reviews)

Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters pairs a perfect rating with same-day roof installs and Hayden's personal attention on every inspection. The score draws on a smaller but perfectly rated set of reviews, and every one of them mentions fair pricing and a clean, straightforward process from tearoff to walkthrough.

• Same-day roof installation on many jobs
• Owner Hayden personally leads inspections
• CertainTeed Select Shingle Master certification
• 50-year warranty backing the work

Services: residential roofing, roof inspection, gutter services

★★★★★5 (49 reviews)

Bald Eagle Roofs & Exteriors built its high score on consistent one-day roof completions with zero debris left behind, led by Herschel's crew and Bill's detailed, photo-backed estimates. Reviewers cover everything from single-family homes to large commercial jobs and storm damage, all handled with the same speed and follow-up.

• One-day roof installations on most jobs
• Zero debris left behind after cleanup
• Named estimator (Bill) who thoroughly inspects and explains options
• Handles residential, commercial, and storm damage work alike

Services: residential roofing, roof repair

★★★★★4.8 (97 reviews)

America's Roofing & Construction Co. scores high on the strength of Dave's hands-on involvement, from fast initial callbacks to walking customers through insurance claims personally. Nearly all recent reviews are five-star, and several mention extras like pressure-washing or gutter painting thrown in at no charge on top of one-day roof replacements.

• Owner Dave personally manages projects from estimate to completion
• One-day completion on full roof replacements
• Specializes in guiding customers through insurance claim language
• Adds extras like pressure-washing and gutter painting at no charge

Services: roof replacement, residential roofing, roof inspection, roof repair

★★★★★4.9 (53 reviews)

Gary Kent Associates has run 37 years in the Chattahoochee Valley, and the review set backs that up with 27 straight five-star ratings and no complaints on record. Gary shows up himself, quotes fair prices upfront, and handles the insurance paperwork that comes with storm damage and aging roofs.

• 37 years in business in the Columbus area
• Owner works alongside the crew on every job
• Same-day or next-day service commonly available
• Handles insurance claims and documentation directly

Services: roof replacement, roof inspection, roof repair

★★★★★4.9 (54 reviews)

All About Roofing & Construction earns its score from Frank Savage's direct, hands-on leadership, with reviewers highlighting one-to-two-day turnarounds on large jobs even in tough weather. The review count is smaller than some on this list, but the pattern is consistent: competitive pricing, meticulous cleanup, and regular photo updates.

• Frank Savage's direct, transparent leadership on every job
• Large jobs completed in one to two days
• Detailed, itemized quotes explained upfront
• Protective measures taken for landscaping and structures

Services: roof inspection, commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement

★★★★★4.9 (120 reviews)

Roofing World handles a high volume of work without the score slipping, with named foremen Ernest, Pierce, and Allen leading crews that start on time and finish full replacements in a single day. Reviewers who hired them point to correct underlayment, proper ventilation, and fire-rated materials as signs of quality beyond just speed.

• One-day completion on full roof replacements
• Named foremen (Ernest, Pierce, Allen) known for professionalism
• Progress photos sent throughout installation
• Transparent material specs explained upfront

Services: residential roofing, metal roofing, roof repair, roof replacement

★★★★★5 (25 reviews)

Matter-of-Fact Roofing holds a perfect rating across a smaller but entirely five-star review set, with Scott and Silas named repeatedly for honesty and patience during insurance negotiations. Reviewers describe inspections that catch damage other contractors missed, plus leaks that stay fixed after the crew leaves.

• Insurance claim navigation and negotiation support
• Named crew (Scott and Silas) known for patience and transparency
• Same-day or next-day response on emergency leaks
• Thorough cleanup and yard protection on every job

Services: roof replacement, residential roofing, roof repair

★★★★★5 (19 reviews)

Baseline Coatings draws its score from a small but perfect run of reviews, most of them describing Matthew personally solving leaks that previous contractors couldn't crack. Customers point to punctual scheduling, fair pricing, and a clean site as reasons they came back for repeat work.

• Owner Matthew personally manages every job
• Solves chronic leaks other contractors missed
• Fair pricing paired with fast turnaround
• Detailed communication and site cleanup

Services: roof replacement, residential roofing, roof repair, gutter services

★★★★★4.6 (91 reviews)

Liberty Roofing Professionals built a large review base around one-day roof work, with Josh, Ky, Mitch, and Mitchell named consistently for clear communication and attentive site management. Financing options and same-day emergency response come up often as reasons customers chose the crew over competitors.

• One-day completion standard on repair and replacement jobs
• Named, experienced crew with consistent site supervision
• Clear communication and job transparency throughout
• Financing options and same-day emergency response available

Services: roof replacement, roof repair

★★★★★5 (17 reviews)

Simply Roofing's perfect rating comes from a smaller review set that consistently describes repairs blending invisibly into existing roofs. Customers highlight the crew catching root causes previous contractors missed, along with clear communication and thorough cleanup on every visit.

• Matched materials that blend repairs invisibly
• Identifies root causes missed by other contractors
• Work completed efficiently without delays
• Repairs that hold up over the long term

Services: commercial roofing, roof replacement, roof repair, residential roofing

★★★★★4.6 (66 reviews)

Danny Renfroe Roofing Co is a father-and-sons operation where Shane and the crew are known for turning down work when a roof doesn't actually need replacing. Reviewers highlight magnetic nail sweeps and thorough debris removal alongside fair pricing, and the recent review pattern runs strongly positive.

• Father-and-sons crew (Danny, Shane, Brandon) known by name
• Magnetic debris sweeps and tarp setup during tear-off
• Honest inspections that decline unnecessary work
• Same-day or next-day completion on full replacements

Services: roof inspection, commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement

★★★★☆4.4 (148 reviews)

Alan Townsend brings 40-plus years in the trade to a large volume of reviews, with customers describing him finding leaks other roofers missed and matching shingles by eye. Many reviewers mention getting an estimate the morning after calling, and several say they trust him enough to refer family.

• Responds same day or next morning on most calls
• Finds leaks other roofers miss
• Fair pricing with no upcharging
• 40-plus years of experience matching shingles

Services: roof inspection, commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement

★★★★★5 (21 reviews)

One Stop Roofing built a perfect rating on a smaller review set where every single review mentions professionalism and speedy scheduling under Freddie Diaz. Most jobs wrap up in a single day, and reviewers consistently call out honest pricing with no upselling and thorough cleanup afterward.

• Owner Freddie Diaz personally oversees projects
• Same-day or next-day turnaround common
• Honest advice with no upselling
• Thorough site cleanup on every job

Services: roof inspection