Best roofing contractors in Columbus
These are the 15 highest-scoring roofing contractors in Columbus, ranked by our methodology, which weighs Google rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment together. Most of these crews cover the same ground (replacements, repairs, storm damage, gutters), so the ranking comes down to how consistently each one delivers on communication, cleanup, and honest pricing.
Picks are ranked by relevance to roofing contractor.
At a glance
| # | Business | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Superior Roofing Columbus | 4.9 (155) | — | Overall pick, honest inspections |
| 2 | Supreme Service Company | 4.9 (69) | — | Full-service remodels and emergencies |
| 3 | Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters Columbus | 5 (50) | — | Same-day roof and gutter combos |
| 4 | Bald Eagle Roofs & Exteriors | 5 (49) | — | One-day installs, storm and commercial jobs |
| 5 | America's Roofing & Construction Co. | 4.8 (97) | — | Insurance claim navigation |
| 6 | Gary Kent Associates | Roofing in Columbus, GA. | 4.9 (55) | — | Experienced, owner-supervised jobs |
| 7 | Roofing World | 4.9 (119) | — | Documented, photo-tracked installs |
| 8 | All About Roofing & Construction | 4.9 (54) | — | Large and commercial jobs on tight timelines |
| 9 | Matter-of-Fact Roofing, LLC | 5 (26) | — | Emergency repairs, no-pressure insurance help |
| 10 | Baseline Coatings | 5 (19) | — | Solving leaks other contractors missed |
| 11 | Liberty Roofing Professionals | 4.6 (91) | — | Financing options, same-day emergencies |
| 12 | Simply Roofing | 5 (17) | — | Invisible repairs that match existing roofs |
| 13 | Summit Roofing Professionals | 5 (12) | — | Personal attention on smaller jobs |
| 14 | Danny Renfroe Roofing Co | 4.6 (66) | — | Family-run, honest assessments |
| 15 | Alan Townsend Roofer | 4.4 (148) | — | Fast response and leak diagnosis |
1. Superior Roofing Columbus
4.9 (155 reviews)
Superior Roofing Columbus posts the highest composite score on this list, built on a 4.9 average across 155 reviews. Brian's team combines free appraisals with a habit of fixing minor issues during the inspection at no charge, and enough customers return for a second project that trust looks earned rather than lucky.
- Free appraisals with no-charge minor repairs
- Brian personally handles consultations and oversees jobs
- Crews leave job sites spotless
- High review volume backs up the rating
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
2. Supreme Service Company
4.9 (69 reviews)
Supreme Service Company is a licensed general contractor with over 20 years behind it, so roofing jobs can extend into gutters or bathroom remodels without bringing in a second company. Jasmine Granville and Dominic run a tight operation known for same-day response on roof emergencies and clear explanations at every stage.
- Licensed GC with 20+ years' history
- Certified installer for Tamko, Atlas, Owens Corning, GAF
- BBB A+ accredited and Columbus Home Builders Association member
- Same-day response on urgent leaks
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
3. Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters Columbus
5 (50 reviews)
Crosby Roofing & Seamless Gutters holds a perfect 5.0 across 50 reviews, with Hayden personally leading inspections and crews regularly finishing tearoff-to-walkthrough in a single day. The CertainTeed Select Shingle Master credential and 50-year warranty back up the speed with real material coverage.
- Same-day roof installation
- Owner personally leads inspections
- CertainTeed Select Shingle Master certified
- 50-year warranty included
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
4. Bald Eagle Roofs & Exteriors
5 (49 reviews)
Bald Eagle Roofs & Exteriors pairs a perfect 5.0 rating with a reputation for finishing residential roofs in a single day and leaving zero debris behind. Bill's detailed estimates and photo updates through Herschel and Levi's crew mean owners aren't guessing what's happening on their roof, and the team handles everything from single homes to commercial buildings.
- One-day roof installations
- Zero debris left on site
- Named estimators who explain options clearly
- Equally comfortable on residential and commercial jobs
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
5. America's Roofing & Construction Co.
4.8 (97 reviews)
America's Roofing & Construction Co. built a 4.8 average across 97 reviews largely on Dave's hands-on approach to insurance claims, walking homeowners through adjuster conversations while his crew completes replacements in a day. Extras like free pressure-washing or gutter painting show up often enough in reviews to count as standard practice, not a fluke.
- Owner Dave manages projects end to end
- One-day completion on full replacements
- Hands-on help with insurance claim language
- Free extras like pressure-washing and gutter painting
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
6. Gary Kent Associates | Roofing in Columbus, GA.
4.9 (55 reviews)
Gary Kent Associates brings 37 years of trade experience to every job, and Gary's habit of personally supervising work shows up repeatedly in the 4.9 rating across 55 reviews. Crews complete single-day replacements when conditions allow and handle storm damage and insurance questions without passing customers off to someone else.
- 37 years of experience
- Owner actively supervises every job
- One-day roof replacements when feasible
- Direct help navigating insurance claims
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
7. Roofing World
4.9 (119 reviews)
Roofing World's 119 reviews at a 4.9 average is the largest sample outside the top two, driven by named project managers (Ernest, Pierce, Allen) who send daily photo updates and stick around for the full job. Poly shingles, fire-and-ice underlayment, and proper drip edge and ventilation are treated as standard, not upsells.
- One-day roof replacements
- Drone photo documentation during install
- Named project managers track jobs start to finish
- Standard use of quality underlayment and ventilation
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
8. All About Roofing & Construction
4.9 (54 reviews)
All About Roofing & Construction turns around large commercial jobs in a day or two even in bad weather, with Frank Savage sending regular photo updates and plain explanations of the timeline. The 4.9 rating across 54 reviews leans heavily on competitive pricing and careful protection of landscaping during the work.
- Jobs completed in one to two days, even large ones
- Detailed itemized quotes
- Protective measures for landscaping and structures
- Direct, transparent communication from ownership
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
9. Matter-of-Fact Roofing, LLC
5 (26 reviews)
Matter-of-Fact Roofing earns a perfect 5.0 across 26 reviews for handling everything from emergency leak calls to full replacements without pushing customers into decisions. Scott and Silas are named repeatedly for walking clients through each step and following up weeks after the job to check the work held.
- Transparent, no-pressure estimates
- Insurance claim advocacy without pressure tactics
- Same-day or next-morning emergency response
- Meticulous cleanup with follow-up checks
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
10. Baseline Coatings
5 (19 reviews)
Baseline Coatings shows a perfect 5.0 rating across 19 reviews, with Matthew personally taking on jobs where prior contractors failed to stop a leak. Customers describe fair pricing and fast turnaround alongside the kind of problem-solving that keeps them calling him back.
- Owner Matthew personally manages jobs
- Fixes chronic leaks other contractors missed
- Fair pricing with fast turnaround
- Clear communication and clean site work
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof repair, residential roofing
11. Liberty Roofing Professionals
4.6 (91 reviews)
Liberty Roofing Professionals covers 91 reviews at a 4.6 average, with named crew members Josh, Ky, Mitch, and Mitchell running single-day repair and replacement jobs with clear upfront communication. Financing options and same-day emergency response are called out often enough to be a real differentiator for budget-conscious homeowners.
- One-day completion standard
- Named crew with consistent site supervision
- Clear communication throughout the job
- Financing options and same-day emergency response
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
12. Simply Roofing
5 (17 reviews)
Simply Roofing holds a perfect 5.0 across 17 reviews for work that blends seamlessly into existing roofing rather than looking patched on. Reviewers point to the crew catching root causes previous contractors missed and matching materials closely enough that repairs disappear.
- Matched materials blend repairs invisibly
- Identifies root causes other crews missed
- Efficient work without delays
- Clear communication throughout
Services: commercial roofing, residential roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
13. Summit Roofing Professionals
5 (12 reviews)
Summit Roofing Professionals has a perfect 5.0 rating, though it comes from a smaller pool of 12 reviews. Davis and Jessie are named repeatedly for answering questions fast and standing behind replacements, repairs, and gutter installs alike.
- Named staff known personally by customers
- Careful property protection and cleanup
- Responsive communication with homeowners and insurers
- Perfect rating across all reviews so far
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
14. Danny Renfroe Roofing Co
4.6 (66 reviews)
Danny Renfroe Roofing Co is a father-and-sons operation where Shane and the crew are known for declining work when a roof still has life left in it, an honesty theme that shows up repeatedly across 66 reviews at a 4.6 average. Magnetic nail sweeps and tarp setup during tearoff back up the cleanup reputation.
- Father-and-sons crew known by name
- Magnetic debris sweeps during removal
- Honest inspections, including declining unnecessary work
- Same-day or next-day completion on replacements
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair
15. Alan Townsend Roofer
4.4 (148 reviews)
Alan Townsend Roofer carries the largest review count on this list at 148, with a 4.4 average built on fast arrival times and a knack for finding leaks other roofers miss after 40 years in the trade. Homeowners mention getting estimates the next morning after calling and trusting him enough to refer family.
- Responds same day or next morning
- Finds leaks other roofers miss
- Fair pricing without upcharging
- 40+ years matching shingles by eye
Services: commercial roofing, metal roofing, roof replacement, roof repair