Gutters do one job: move roof water away from your foundation, siding, and landscaping before it can pool, freeze, or find a crack to exploit. In Columbus, that job gets harder every winter and spring, when freeze-thaw cycles and heavy spring rain expose sagging sections, loose hangers, and undersized downspouts. This category covers the 25 local businesses that install new gutter systems, repair or reseal existing ones, add gutter guards, and handle the fascia and soffit work that often comes with it.
Most Columbus homes get seamless aluminum gutters, formed on-site from coil stock to fit the house exactly, which cuts down on the leak-prone joints you get with sectional gutters. A proper job includes correct pitch toward the downspouts (roughly a quarter-inch of drop per 10 feet), enough downspouts to handle the roof's square footage, and hangers spaced tightly enough to hold up under ice and debris. Repair calls are usually about resealing seams, re-pitching a sagging run, replacing rotted fascia boards underneath, or fixing downspouts that dump water right at the foundation instead of away from it.
We rank the 25 gutter companies in this category using the same consistent criteria across every listing, so you're comparing apples to apples instead of relying on whoever has the flashiest ad. See the full breakdown and every company's standing in our ranked guide to Columbus roofing contractors, and read exactly how we score and weight each factor in our methodology.
Get matched with gutter installation & repair in Columbus
Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.
25 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is gutter installation & repair, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Matthew leads Baseline Coatings with hands-on professionalism that stands apart. Customers consistently report he solves persistent roof issues (including leaks prior contractors failed to fix), arrives on schedule, keeps them informed, and charges fairly. Work quality and cleanliness after jobs wrap up earn repeat business.
When Weather Shielders shows up, work quality and pricing satisfy most customers, with Shane earning particular praise for honesty and budget flexibility. Repeat no-shows, unreturned calls, and at least one warranty dispute that went unresolved create a serious reliability risk.
Strong work on initial jobs and emergency response, but serious follow-up problems. Several older reviews praise quick repairs and insurance coordination, yet others report warranty claims abandoned for months and no-shows on scheduled visits. Recent complaints about unpaid vendor invoices and unanswered calls suggest operational strain.
Crosby Roofing delivers consistent five-star service across roof and gutter work. Hayden and his crew earn praise for quick callbacks, transparent pricing, and finishing jobs the same day. Customers highlight the owner's personal attention and crew professionalism, from roof tearoff to final walkthrough, making the experience straightforward and reliable.
Reviewers consistently report fast, thorough work with named staff-Jasmine and Dominic Granville appear frequently-handling everything from emergency roof repairs to full renovations. The business responds the same day, completes jobs on time, and cleans up so thoroughly customers note the site looks untouched. Communication stands out: staff explain work as it happens, answer questions promptly, and keep homeowners informed at each step, especially valuable during insurance claims and storm damage. Their certifications (Tamko, Atlas, Owens Corning, GAF installer; state-licensed general contractor; BBB A+) anchor the praise. Storm damage and insurance work feature prominently in reviews. One caller reached Dominic after hours for an emergency repair. Gutter installation, roof replacement, and bathroom remodeling all earned five-star ratings with mentions of extra work (replacing facial boards) done without being asked.
Get matched with gutter installation & repair in Columbus
Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.
Frank Savage and his crew deliver roof replacements and commercial work with speed, often finishing large jobs in a day or two despite challenging weather. Reviewers consistently note competitive pricing, meticulous cleanup, and Frank's hands-on communication style, with regular photo updates and plain explanations of options and timelines.
Most customers praise Danny Renfroe Roofing for on-time service, thorough cleanup including magnetic nail sweeps, and fair pricing. Shane Renfroe and the crew earn consistent respect for quality work, honest assessments (declining jobs when roofs don't need replacement), and going beyond the original scope. Two early complaints cite missed appointments and billing disputes; the recent pattern is strongly positive.
Alan Townsend arrives fast, finds leaks other roofers miss, and prices fairly. His crew works cleanly and finishes fast, matching shingles by eye after 40 years in the trade. One complaint alleges incomplete work on vents and flashing three years ago, leaving the homeowner needing repairs elsewhere. Reviewers trust him enough to refer family and handle storm damage while waiting on insurance. He does roof repairs, replacements, and inspections across Columbus and surrounding areas, often completing jobs in a day or less. Many mention getting estimates the next morning after calling.
Reviewers consistently report projects completed on time with no surprises: Steve's estimates are accurate, his crew works methodically and cleans up afterward, and both owner and installers explain why work matters. Windows dominate the testimonials-replacements that fit and finish perfectly-but gutter installs, roof repairs, and door work receive equal praise for attention to detail and fair pricing compared to competing quotes. Several customers note Steve's willingness to catch problems other companies missed (misaligned gutters, trim defects) and fix them proactively. The business has served multiple homes for the same families since 2023, and repeat customers credit consistent quality. Crews are named often: JP, Nick, Kevin, and Christina stand out for courtesy and speed. No substantive complaints appear in the review set.
Affordable Home Repair shows extreme inconsistency: a handful of five-star reviews praise fast response and fair pricing on minor jobs, but 17 of the 30 reviews document abandonment mid-project, poor workmanship, communication breakdowns after the initial sale, and unresolved issues. The business appears to accept work it cannot complete. Review evidence is limited to general contracting complaints; roofing-specific feedback is sparse.
When a named technician is assigned, work is solid and communication stays on track. Project delays and office communication lapses are the consistent friction point, especially on insurance claims where estimates have been bungled and timelines stretch far beyond initial forecasts.
Alan and his team consistently solve roof problems other contractors miss, often fixing leaks and damage the same day they assess the site. Reviewers praise their professionalism, transparent communication, competitive rates, and thoroughness on older homes and complex jobs.
Best Choice Roofing delivers reliable service with strong staff communication. Reviews highlight responsive sales, quality repairs, and warranty work handled without extra cost.
Stormproof's 4.3 rating rests on consistent praise for Donovan's team: clients highlight fast, clean work and clear updates. Five five-star reviews praise professionalism and finishing touches. One low rating creates a caution flag, but detail on that complaint is missing.
Greer Home Solutions delivers strong results on smaller, specific jobs when staff stay engaged, but larger projects attract complaints about absent leadership, unskilled subs, and poor communication. The company's responsiveness and cost vary widely job to job; older reviews praise affordability and professionalism, while recent feedback flags unprofessional handling and structural defects like shower leaks a year later.
All four reviews award five stars. Christian leads consultations with strong product knowledge and follows through on commitments. Teams finish jobs quickly, work hard, and leave sites clean, though one reviewer noted nails scattered around the roof edge afterward.
One Google review rates this Columbus business five stars. Detail is limited, so broader assessment depends on their stated 10+ years of experience and service range.
Limited review data. One five-star rating supports the business's emergency and restoration claims, though detail on specific services remains scarce.
One five-star review recommends the business, though limited detail is available. Their website claims to offer roof repair, replacement, metal roofing, inspections, and gutter services across Columbus and nearby areas.
Positive reviews praise flooring, bathroom, and interior renovation work with punctual completion. Serious complaints center on Casey (a named employee/representative) over payment disputes, unprofessional behavior online, and unresolved roof leaks after installation with disputed or missing warranty documentation. Recent reviews and one five-star for roofing contrast sharply with two unresolved one-star roof complaints from 2018-2019.
Long-standing customers praise the company for roof repairs on century-old homes and honouring warranties. Earlier no-show incidents and communication lapses raise caution.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
No customer reviews are available for this business. To assess service quality and reliability, check their phone number or website directly for references or recent customer feedback.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Enquiries submitted through our forms may be passed to partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-08-26