Georgia Roofing Roster
Menu

Roof Replacement in Rome

Roof Replacement in Georgia

A full roof replacement means stripping the existing roofing material down to the deck, repairing or replacing damaged sheathing, installing new underlayment and flashing, and laying new shingles, metal panels, tile, or another covering. It's a bigger job than a repair or a partial overlay: on most homes it takes anywhere from one to several days, involves a dumpster or trailer for tear-off debris, and requires a crew large enough to get the deck dried in before weather turns. This category lists 22 contractors serving Rome who take on full re-roofs, from standard asphalt shingle jobs to metal and specialty roofing.

What a re-roof actually involves

Beyond swapping old shingles for new ones, a proper replacement includes a deck inspection (rotten or soft plywood gets replaced, not covered over), ice-and-water shield in valleys and along eaves where local code or climate calls for it, new drip edge and step flashing around chimneys and walls, and ridge or soffit ventilation that actually moves air through the attic. Skipping any of these steps is how a roof that looks fine in year one starts leaking by year five.

What to check before you hire

  • Licensing and insurance: ask for proof of both, and confirm workers' comp covers the actual crew doing the work, not just a subcontractor's paperwork.
  • Manufacturer certification: certified installers can usually offer stronger, longer manufacturer warranties on materials like GAF or Owens Corning shingles.
  • A written scope: the quote should spell out tear-off, deck repair pricing (per sheet), underlayment type, flashing details, and ventilation, not just "$X per square."
  • Local references: a contractor who's done recent roofs in Rome knows how the area's storms and heat cycles wear on materials, and can point you to homes to look at.
  • Cleanup plan: nail magnets and debris hauling should be spelled out, not assumed.

How our scoring works

We rank these 22 contractors on factors like review volume and rating trends, responsiveness, and consistency of service over time, not paid placement. For the full breakdown of how a score is built, see our methodology page. To see how these contractors stack up against each other, check the ranked guide to roofing contractors in Rome.

Get matched with roof replacement in Rome

Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.

Get matched

All roof replacement in Rome, ranked by score and relevance

We found 22 businesses offering roof replacement in Rome; 21 met the criteria for the scored directory. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is roof replacement, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.

Midian Roofing Inc.
#1
93

Midian Roofing Inc.

4.9(502)✓ Google-verified

Work runs from early morning to completion the same day, with crews arriving before dawn and managers calling the day before to confirm details and answer questions. Named technicians like James Justice, Kevin Weaver, Brandon, Grant, Terry, Scott Hutchens, Cody Rose, and Hunter are consistently praised for patience, knowledge, and professionalism, while cleanup involves nail magnets and tarping that often leaves properties cleaner than they started. Staff tackle emergency tarps outside their normal area and revisit jobs to fix mistakes at no charge, treating warranty claims with transparency. A mother seeking a carport repair got work completed that went beyond the original scope, and a long-standing customer's inspection call resulted in an honest assessment that ruled out a $14,500 replacement, saving the homeowner money despite zero pressure to upsell.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Wii Care Plus, LLC
#2
84

Wii Care Plus, LLC

4.9(42)✓ Google-verified

Wii Care Plus delivers consistent quality across roofing, decking, and remodeling work. Reviewers note that Jeremy and his crew show up on time, explain the work as they go, treat homes with care, and clean up after themselves. Roof replacements and repairs are completed promptly with careful attention to insurance documentation and material quality.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingResidential Roofing
Camco Roofing Services LLC
#3
82

Camco Roofing Services LLC

5.0(18)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Every interaction reviewers describe centers on speed without cutting corners. Roofs get replaced in a day. Phone calls get answered immediately. Insurance paperwork gets walked through. Named staff-Michael, Jamie, Miles, Jessie, Andrew, Tom-appear repeatedly across jobs, suggesting continuity and accountability. Customers notice what happens after the work ends: spotless yards, follow-up calls, no surprises on the invoice. The company leans into services others avoid. Roof rejuvenation gets chosen over full replacement when it makes sense, even if replacement would cost more. Metal roofing, flat roofs, storm tarping all appear in reviews as delivered competently. One reviewer caught them honoring that ethic directly: their inspector said "no new roof needed," recommended rejuvenation instead, and the company agreed.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Buckhead Roofing
#4
82

Buckhead Roofing

4.9(609)✓ Google-verified

Most reviewers report clean, honest work at quoted prices. Crews show up on time, finish jobs without upselling, and explain repairs clearly, even across language barriers. The company has handled complex coordination (solar panel removal, after-hours service for small businesses, matching existing materials) without passing blame. Recent negative reviews detail months of miscommunication, unannounced arrivals, unfinished jobs, and deposit disputes on larger projects. Complaints center on lack of follow-up from management, shingle supply issues causing work stoppages, and additional charges beyond the initial estimate.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Amigo Roofing
#5
81

Amigo Roofing

5.0(15)✓ Google-verified

Amigo Roofing delivers roof replacements and repairs with a focus on speed and value. Reviewers consistently praise the team's efficiency, competitive pricing, and spotless cleanup; jobs often finish the same day they start. Mario and the crew handle residential replacements, commercial TPO work, and gutter installations with attention to detail and no surprises.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair

Get matched with roof replacement in Rome

Free, no obligation. Describe your roofing job and we'll match you with qualified contractors.

Get matched
Georgia Metal Center
#6
79 low data

Georgia Metal Center

4.9(24)✓ Google-verified

Georgia Metal Center earns consistent praise for knowledgeable staff, competitive pricing, and reliable turnaround on metal supplies and roofing materials. Reviewers value their family-owned roots and straightforward honesty in dealing.

Metal RoofingRoof ReplacementCommercial Roofing
Brax Exteriors
#7
77 low data

Brax Exteriors

4.7(39)✓ Google-verified

Brax Exteriors executes roofing and gutter work reliably, with crews arriving on time and leaving sites clean. Most customers praise professionalism and fair pricing, though one reported multiple vent leaks within two years of a $13,000 roof replacement.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Cornerstone gutter & leaf guard specialist
#8
73 low data

Cornerstone gutter & leaf guard specialist

4.6(43)✓ Google-verified

Most jobs earn five-star praise for Todd's crew professionalism, fast work, and quality installs. Several recent reviews, however, cite unresolved leaks, warranty denials, and repeated failures on the same jobs, leaving customers frustrated and out of pocket for re-dos elsewhere.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Camco Services
#9
70 low data

Camco Services

4.2(18)✓ Google-verified

Strong track record on roof replacement and water damage restoration for homeowners. Crew professionalism and insurance claim handling stand out, though some customers report gaps in follow-up scheduling and communication after deposit payment.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingResidential Roofing
Atlas Roofing & Restoration
#10
69 low data

Atlas Roofing & Restoration

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Atlas has earned a 5-star average on both recent reviews. A property management company praised them for handling repairs and installations of all sizes with consistent professionalism and attention to detail over a year of work. A residential customer highlighted their same-day quoting, prompt answers to every call, on-time arrival, and decision to spec premium shingles without premium pricing.

Roof ReplacementResidential RoofingRoof Repair
Honest Abe Roofing of Northwest Georgia
#11
68 low data

Honest Abe Roofing of Northwest Georgia

5.0(8)✓ Google-verified

All eight reviews rate Honest Abe five stars. Reviewers consistently praise David (owner), Bryan, and Valerie for showing up on time, answering questions quickly, and staying on top of the job from start to finish. Fair pricing and friendly service run through every account.

Roof ReplacementGutter Installation & RepairResidential Roofing
American Roofing Company
#12
64 low data

American Roofing Company

4.8(16)✓ Google-verified

Most reviews describe swift, professional roof replacements with thorough cleanup. One older complaint alleged poor workmanship and unresolved property damage.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingResidential Roofing
Brannon & Son Roofing and Construction
#13
62 low data

Brannon & Son Roofing and Construction

4.0(22)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers report sharp contrasts in experience. Many praise Gary Brannon and Neil for reliability, fair costs, and clean work on repairs and replacements. Others describe poor workmanship, failures to return for promised follow-up, and refusals to correct defects, leaving them to hire competitors to redo the job.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
McCullough Roofing & Metal Works
#14
62 low data

McCullough Roofing & Metal Works

5.0(4)✓ Google-verified

All four reviewers gave five stars. The team's strongest reputation comes from fast emergency response after storm damage, willingness to work holidays, and thorough inspections that uncover concerns beyond the initial request. Reviewers consistently praise the crew's professionalism, friendliness, and fair rates.

Metal RoofingRoof ReplacementCommercial Roofing
Cargle Brothers & Co Inc
#15
61 low data

Cargle Brothers & Co Inc

4.8(4)✓ Google-verified

Doug, Chuck, and their team deliver roof replacements with transparent pricing and reliable follow-through. Work stays on schedule and budget, with a genuine warranty backing it.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Roofers of Rome, LLC
#16
61 low data

Roofers of Rome, LLC

5.0(9)✓ Google-verified

All nine reviews are five-star. Work spans roof replacement, gutter installation, and repairs on residential and rental properties. Reviewers consistently mention responsive communication, professional staff (Zach named specifically), fair pricing, and help navigating insurance claims.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Rome Georgia Roofers
#17
55 low data

Rome Georgia Roofers

4.0(4)✓ Google-verified

Two older five-star reviews praised insurance claim support and workmanship, but a recent one-star review raised concerns about company identity and a referral-based inspection process that did not suit the reviewer's needs. Evidence is limited across just 3 reviews spanning years.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingGutter Installation & Repair
Silicone Coating Solutions
#18
52 low data

Silicone Coating Solutions

5.0(1)✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Roof ReplacementRoof Repair
Bannister Roofing
#19
47 low data

Bannister Roofing

3.0(6)✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Roof ReplacementCommercial RoofingResidential Roofing
David Shiflett Roofing
#20
44 low data

David Shiflett Roofing

3.3(4)

One customer praised their roof replacement as professional and timely with excellent cleanup. Another reported a post-installation leak around the chimney that required repeated contact attempts to resolve, leaving them frustrated after paying for a full roof.

Roof ReplacementResidential Roofing
A-1 Roof Repair Specialest
#21
22 low data

A-1 Roof Repair Specialest

No rating yet

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Roof ReplacementResidential RoofingRoof Repair

Get quotes from our featured partners

How many quotes would you like?

By sending this enquiry you agree that we share it with providers relevant to your request.

Enquiries submitted through our forms may be passed to partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not affected by referral fees.

Common questions about roof replacement

How much does a roof replacement cost?
It depends heavily on roof size, pitch, and material. Asphalt shingle replacements typically run from a few thousand dollars for a small, simple roof up into the five figures for a large or steep one, and metal or tile roofing costs more per square than shingles. Get itemized quotes from at least three contractors in this category so you're comparing the same scope of work, not just a bottom-line number.
How often does a roof actually need to be replaced?
Asphalt shingle roofs generally last 15 to 30 years depending on the shingle grade, ventilation, and how much direct sun and storm exposure the roof gets. Metal roofing can last 40 to 70 years. If your roof is past 20 years old, has curling or missing shingles, granule loss showing up in gutters, or daylight visible through the attic decking, it's worth getting an inspection rather than waiting for a leak.
What should I expect on installation day?
Expect noise, a dumpster or debris trailer in the driveway, and the crew stripping the old roof down to bare deck before inspecting it for rot. A single-layer asphalt shingle job on an average house often finishes in a day; larger, steeper, or multi-layer tear-offs can take two or three. Cover or move items in the attic and garage beforehand, since the vibration shakes loose dust and debris.
How can I judge whether the finished work is good quality?
Check that shingle lines are straight and courses are aligned, flashing around chimneys and vents is new (not just caulked over the old flashing), nail heads aren't exposed, and ridge vents sit flush. Ask for photos of the deck before it was covered, since that's the part you won't see again. A contractor who's confident in their work will walk the roof with you or provide a post-install walkthrough.

Last updated 2026-08-26