A1roofman delivers quick, polished work on good days but earns most of its low rating (3.3/5) from broken warranties, no-shows on follow-up calls, and pricing that shifts sharply between quote and site visit. Older five-star reviews praise Jay Diamond's hands-on style and crew professionalism; recent one and two-star reviews detail leaks within months, abandoned elderly homeowners, and warranty refusals.
Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.
Joey Knight's crew typically delivers work on schedule, cleans up well, and prices fairly, earning 69% five-star reviews. However, a meaningful minority report unresolved leaks, ignored warranty callbacks, and poor follow-up. Most recent positive reviews praise reliability and reasonable costs, but older cases show patterns of slow response when problems emerge months after installation.
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Two five-star reviews highlight United Roofing's speed and quality. A crew completed a 93-square roof in two days while maintaining standards under owner Moises's oversight. One reviewer called them the best roofing company in Columbus.
Last updated 2026-08-26